Album Review Guidelines

Album Reviews Forum

Rules!

1) Do not just post any old album review whenever you feel like it. Let's make this Well Ordered
2) We will agree on who writes each review by discussing it
3) The reviewer must review each track on the album (excluding Japanese bonus tracks if the reviewer does not have them)
4) The reviewer must give an official rating from 1-5 stars
5) We won't review loads of bands that nobody likes (unless we agree on that)
6) There is no number 6!


Reply To This Post With The Album That You Think Should Be Reviewed First And Then We Will Choose One That ONE Of Us Will Review


Get Posting --- PMLO

i think somehow you got the idea of a review forum by the review of ultra beatdown i did lol. I'll edit it if you want with all those things you said and we can put it in the review forum.

TCJacko wrote:

i think somehow you got the idea of a review forum by the review of ultra beatdown i did lol. I'll edit it if you want with all those things you said and we can put it in the review forum.

yeah it was your post that did it

yeah edit your ultra beatdown review and then move it (or i can) ....as you are a moderator

PowerMetalLivesOn wrote:

TCJacko wrote:

i think somehow you got the idea of a review forum by the review of ultra beatdown i did lol. I'll edit it if you want with all those things you said and we can put it in the review forum.

yeah it was your post that did it

yeah edit your ultra beatdown review and then move it (or i can) ....as you are a moderator

will do.

kamelot the black halo

trust me i'm qualified, kamelot is my all time favorite power metal band, and this is my all time favorite album by them

balrog wrote:

kamelot the black halo

trust me i'm qualified, kamelot is my all time favorite power metal band, and this is my all time favorite album by them

GO ON BALROG

go for it and do the review

remember to follow all the guidelines

(makes me feel kinda bad now ....as i was just forced to hurt kamelot in 'battle of the bands')

sorry

I'll review Turisas - The Varganian Way. It's not REALLY old...

Rokai wrote:

I'll review Turisas - The Varganian Way. It's not REALLY old...

so we have

Rokai - Turisas - The Varangian Way
PowerMetalLivesOn - DragonForce - Valley Of The Damned
TCJacko - DragonForce - Inhuman Rampage (if he wants to do it) - he hasnt been online since it was suggested
Balrog - Kamelot - The Black Halo


let's get writing

and then post them with the name

'Artist Name' - 'Album Name' - Album Review

may i please do black holes and revealations by muse? i know it's not power metal, but they're my favorite band outside of power metal. and they're very good

balrog wrote:

may i please do black holes and revealations by muse? i know it's not power metal, but they're my favorite band outside of power metal. and they're very good

unless anyone else really objects to it

but your kamelot review was good so go ahead

PowerMetalLivesOn wrote:

Rokai wrote:

I'll review Turisas - The Varganian Way. It's not REALLY old...

so we have

Rokai - Turisas - The Varangian Way
PowerMetalLivesOn - DragonForce - Valley Of The Damned
TCJacko - DragonForce - Inhuman Rampage (if he wants to do it) - he hasnt been online since it was suggested
Balrog - Kamelot - The Black Halo


let's get writing

and then post them with the name

'Artist Name' - 'Album Name' - Album Review

Yeah I will do Inhuman Rampage. and you missed out my ultra beatdown review on the list

TCJacko wrote:

PowerMetalLivesOn wrote:

Rokai wrote:

I'll review Turisas - The Varganian Way. It's not REALLY old...

so we have

Rokai - Turisas - The Varangian Way
PowerMetalLivesOn - DragonForce - Valley Of The Damned
TCJacko - DragonForce - Inhuman Rampage (if he wants to do it) - he hasnt been online since it was suggested
Balrog - Kamelot - The Black Halo


let's get writing

and then post them with the name

'Artist Name' - 'Album Name' - Album Review

Yeah I will do Inhuman Rampage. and you missed out my ultra beatdown review on the list

well actually that was just a list of reviews that hadnt been written yet

and your ultra beatdown one was already up by then


but rest assured we all know it was a great review

I'm thinking i may give my thoughts on the new Edguy album "Tinnitus Sanctus".
Dunno yet.

PowerMetalLivesOn wrote:

TCJacko wrote:

PowerMetalLivesOn wrote:

Rokai wrote:

I'll review Turisas - The Varganian Way. It's not REALLY old...

so we have

Rokai - Turisas - The Varangian Way
PowerMetalLivesOn - DragonForce - Valley Of The Damned
TCJacko - DragonForce - Inhuman Rampage (if he wants to do it) - he hasnt been online since it was suggested
Balrog - Kamelot - The Black Halo


let's get writing

and then post them with the name

'Artist Name' - 'Album Name' - Album Review

Yeah I will do Inhuman Rampage. and you missed out my ultra beatdown review on the list

well actually that was just a list of reviews that hadnt been written yet

and your ultra beatdown one was already up by then


but rest assured we all know it was a great review

lol thanks man.

Can I do a review on "Amon Amarth - Twilight Of The Thunder God", or is it to old?

MetalNiller wrote:

Can I do a review on "Amon Amarth - Twilight Of The Thunder God", or is it to old?

nope not too old, go for it

can i do Nightwish - Dark Passion Play

yoshimitsublade13 wrote:

can i do Nightwish - Dark Passion Play

go ahead

PowerMetalLivesOn wrote:

MetalNiller wrote:

Can I do a review on "Amon Amarth - Twilight Of The Thunder God", or is it to old?

nope not too old, go for it

Thank u!

I've been thinking of doing a review on the brand new "Crack The Skye" album by Mastodon.

Jenul wrote:

I've been thinking of doing a review on the brand new "Crack The Skye" album by Mastodon.

that would be great. because I haven't heard it and sooo...I need to get opinions

PowerMetalLivesOn wrote:

Jenul wrote:

I've been thinking of doing a review on the brand new "Crack The Skye" album by Mastodon.

that would be great. because I haven't heard it and sooo...I need to get opinions

Haha, cool.

Well, i'm done with the review know. Should I post it?

yeah, in a seperate topic that would be great

Okay, I'm uploading it now.