Anette Or Tarja?

Which Nightwish female singer do you prefer?

I vote for Anette because I just love the sound much more!

LOL, sorry but Tarja wipes the floor with anette, no contest.
Nightwish sounded Power Metal before and they were unique but now they sound just like any other band like Lacuna Coil or Evanescence.
I like Anette though and i like nightwish with her but it's just ridiculous to put these 2 up against each other.
I think either Simone Simmons of Epica or Sharon from Within Temptation or Floor Jansen of After forever or even Elisa of Dark moor/Dreamaker would be a better match for Tarja than Tarja Vs Anette.

Anyway, I'm tired of this anette tarja battle, it's getting like Metallica vs Megadeth now, lulz.

notice that i am not pitting them against eachother really

all i am asking is who people prefer

and so far, you have given your opinion and i have given mine

so it's not really a 'who is better?' poll

it is more of just an opinion poll

of course tarja!!! note that about a month ago some girls told me that they hear nightwish. of course you will all think that this is good but guess what. the same girls listen to justin timberlake , miley cyrus and stuff like these so nightwish have became more than underrated with anette in the band. now they sound more pop than metal plus we will NEVER hear the old good songs as anette doesnt have strong vocals.

in conclusion anette sucks!

Ugh! I absolutely HATE Anette.

And I still don't like female vocalists.

I like them both, still voted Anette, bacause i heared her first and made me listining NW

i voted for tarja. i like her sound better.

I can't decide. They are completely different to my ears, and I don't know how to compare them

tarja was the best but it is gone, like alice cooper cover song gone(poison), so we will all remember the greatness that was, but i still listin to nightwish, oh yeah you could always go for the Marco's the better vocalist now argument

Tarja was good, but Anette is also good, so quite a difficult choice.

There are so many bands now that sound like the Nightwish with Tarja, such as Operatika.

Tbh though, the Tarja solo album is not great...

Tarja was good, but Anette is also good, so quite a difficult choice.

There are so many bands now that sound like the Nightwish with Tarja, such as Operatika.

Tbh though, the Tarja solo album is not great...

I like Anette better she just goes better with the band as a whole

and as far as the new album sounding different they had all the music written and everything recorded minus vocals prior to even knowing who their new singer was gonna be

if you don't think Anette sounds metal just listen to Sahara or 7 days to the Wolves

all in all I must say Dark Passion Play is my favorite album thus far from anyone