The Unforgiven I, II or III ?!

Subject: The Unforgiven I, II or III ?! Tue Mar 30, 2010 1:35 pm

Hmmmmmmmmm. I was wondering. Maybe there's not a lot of Metallica fans around here but, I want to know which Unforgiven do you prefer Very Happy

?!

Subject: Re: The Unforgiven I, II or III ?! Wed Mar 31, 2010 4:40 am

the 3rd one should not be called as an Unforgiven...it is quite catchy though but it never reminded me of Metallica. As for I and II they are equal to me but i'd chose the second one only for personal reasons xD

Subject: Re: The Unforgiven I, II or III ?! Wed Mar 31, 2010 6:35 am

Hard to decide between 1 and 2, but let's vote for the original.

Subject: Re: The Unforgiven I, II or III ?! Wed Mar 31, 2010 6:32 pm

NightwalkerRicku wrote:: the 3rd one should not be called as an Unforgiven...it is quite catchy though but it never reminded me of Metallica. As for I and II they are equal to me but i'd chose the second one only for personal reasons xD

I got to agree. I actually find the 3rd one pretty good but it's indeed really different from original Metallica (and original Unforgiven).

Subject: Re: The Unforgiven I, II or III ?! Mon May 31, 2010 7:27 am

The first wins it for me. Apparently the whole Unforgiven 'series' is about Hetfield's childhood life, and how his sister died of a completely curable form of cancer, which wasn't cured all because of his parents' religion. They're all pretty good, but Unforgiven I is the most powerful for me.

Subject: Re: The Unforgiven I, II or III ?! Tue Jun 08, 2010 3:38 am

BuzzPhil wrote:

NightwalkerRicku wrote:: the 3rd one should not be called as an Unforgiven...it is quite catchy though but it never reminded me of Metallica. As for I and II they are equal to me but i'd chose the second one only for personal reasons xD

I got to agree. I actually find the 3rd one pretty good but it's indeed really different from original Metallica (and original Unforgiven).

Ditto. One and two are pretty much a tie. (I'll vote for one though.) While three is good, and is somewhat in the same boat as far as the others, it doesn't attempt to continue the story or anything. I don't really think it should count as a 'squeal'.